top of page

Get Your Pizza Fix!

573878301_1574876820566397_5418066075211985001_n.jpg

"The best pizza 
in all of Baraboo"
~Matt F

526689345_1491811352206278_3481355218294639979_n.jpg

The Menu

Experience the best New York–style, authentic homemade Italian dishes right in the heart of downtown Baraboo, where every meal brings bold flavors and fresh ingredients.

Ordering Pickup
Or Delivery?

We’ve got your back. Order your classic Mama Mia’s favorites on DoorDash or grab pickup through Toast. Get the Mama Mia’s flavors you love, anytime and anywhere.

545675790_1528546705199409_4309293998807754871_n.jpg

fresh ingredients!

555528739_1540663117321101_9058944975835836962_n.jpg
515439994_1492445172142896_3978893693345011662_n.jpg
518242137_1482483109805769_7796650875919330653_n.jpg
518463924_1482483119805768_6537852768933866809_n.jpg

Yummy Reviews

Cozy little atmosphere. Family focused by a family-operated business. They treat you well and work very hard to give you a welcomed feast. You NEVER leave hungry.

Seth Taft

True Italian restaurant with real Italians cooking and serving. Excellent food, great service. Great atmosphere. The smaller the hole in the wall, the better the food. Awesome little place, will visit again

Anna G.

Super impressed with this place! The staff was attentive, thoughtful, and courteous. My mother and I split the spinach ravioli and it came out in two separate dishes for us, and the mamma mia pizza. Everything was just perfect. The bathroom was so clean and well stocked. I can't wait to dine with mamma mia again!

Guy D.

Order Online!

bottom of page